Monday, July 28, 2008

News From Dover

First attempt a failure at 7 hours, 40 minutes, and just over half way to France.

My first attempt to become the oldest person to swim across the English Channel failed after 7 hours and 40 minutes due principally to incredibly painful cramps of the thighs and from intense nausea and gut pains that limited what I could intake at the hourly feeding. However, I have another date set for September 4. Having invested so much effort in this enterprise, I had booked two dates, but I must now decide to stay here and try again or to toss in the towel.

I could not have asked for a better day weather-wise. The sun occasionally broke through a high cloud cover and, most importantly, the wind was next to calm: swells and gentle waves – no white caps.

I have no excuses, but I experienced several problems.

1. After the first feed stop from a squeezable bottle attached by string to the feeder, I began to experience stomach pains and soon nausea. I was using a highly recommended carbohydrate powder known as Maxim mixed with water or beverages. Most swimmers here use it. I have also, and haven’t found it to be as much of a gut problem as, for instance, Gatorade. Two hours later I couldn’t take much in the way of nutrients, only a third of a banana at one stop. I even tried to throw up but could not. So I began to experience a serious shortage of nutrition.

2. The tidal currents were stronger than expected, even for the first day of the neap. The pilot told Catherine and I after it was over that if we’d had the expected currents I would have been two-thirds of the way across – not halfway. But in my mind I would have had to be at least 7/8 the of the way across to have been able to hold on because of the cramps.

3. The water remained at 58 F (12 C), whereas it should be at 62 F (13.5 C) or higher by this date. However I did use two small tubs (peanut butter jar size) of a mixture of Vaseline and lanoline and entered the water via ladder from the boat carefully for it to chill and set the mixture at which point it turns white. I then swam ashore, exited, collected my thoughts, waved my arms and entered again to start the swim. Within 20 minutes the grease had gone from the anterior arm due to the slapping which occurs as the arm enters the water to begin the pull, and the grease on the thigh, which Catherine had applied very liberally and well, had for the most part gone, leaving several streaks as though I had been scratched by a hand with broad fingernails. So not much for insulation. At my age, men when they gain weight do so on the gut while the limbs remain with little subcutaneous fat. The thighs soon became very cold.

By the fifth hour I was getting cramp first in my left anterior thigh and later in the right. By the sixth hours I was trying to kick away the cramp by flexing fully my knee joints. By the seventh hour I had to stop to pull the heel to the buttock to stretch the anterior thigh but to little lasting help. The pain of the cramp slowed my swim from a steady 48-50 strokes per minute to a low 40. It was clear to all that I was struggling. While only I could feel the pain others could see the struggle and they noticed something else: my lips were very swollen and not of a healthy color, signifying the onset of hypothermia. However I was mentally clear and at my last feed clearly communicated my problems. And I heard their concerns.

At 7 hours, 40 minutes, I was defeated. They put the ladder over the side. I pulled myself clear of the water to mid-thigh testing and showing that my arms were still strong. But my legs were useless on the ladder and so I had to be hoisted the rest of the way by the pilot and assistant.

I, of course, was bitterly disappointed. The family and crew as well as Observer/Referee by contrast could only congratulate me in the circumstances.

Now I must decide whether or not to try again on September 4. For this to be the case the following will need change:

1. The water must warm to at least 62 F

2. I must find foods that I can ingest and digest while swimming

3. It must be an equally calm day

4. I will need to get re-motivated, and at this point that will be very difficult

I am positively exhausted and bored out of my mind by the long hours of swimming. Perhaps I peaked too soon and too often, but to time it again might be too much.

I am the oldest ever to have tried to swim the Channel and would have added some 347 days to the record had I succeeded. Perhaps, however, I will have to decide that the effort was valiant enough – that I have had some success and move on. The Foundation has been helped and the profile of physical therapy hasn’t been harmed.

I shall keep you informed probably two weeks from now. In the meantime again thanks to all of you. Sorry to disappoint but sometimes the impossible might just be that.

P.S. This was written two hours after the swim was over and after a hot bath in dishing washing detergent! Now to sleep.




Support Physical Therapy Research!
I am attempting to become the oldest person to swim across the English Channel in order to raise money for physical therapy research. Learn more in the links below.

Please support my effort by making pledges or donations online or by phone at 800-875-1378.

All proceeds benefit physical therapy research!

For more information, see www.apta.org/parisswim.


My Mission & Vision
My Passion
A Plea for Pledges

Thank you for your support!

32 comments:

Patrice W said...

A well deserved rest. I thought of you and this quest several times this weekend. If only the variables would cooperate to your advantage. Thank you for your tentacity and example. You continue to be an inspiration.

Anonymous said...

Stanley - How could we APTA members be anything but overwhelmingly proud of you? Few would have the courage and fortitude to embark on this endeaver. Should you decide to try again I will be there in spirit calling on all the power of the Universe to guide you to a sucessful conclusion. Whether you try again or not you will always be a Hero.
Thank-you so much for all you have done for our profession and for the Foundation.
Dorothy Santi

Gary S said...

Seems like the first attempt just came up a little short, but hardly a failure! Sounds like you know what needs to be corrected for the next attempt.....whenever that may be. Always an inspiration!

John Gray said...

Stanley - Congratulations to you for getting physical therapy in the news, raising tens of thousands of dollars for the Foundation, getting the Foundation for Physical Therapy on the minds of thousands of PTs who have paid very little attention to the Foundation and its purpose in the past, for inspiring baby boomers (and their elders) the world over to rethink what is physically possible at any age, and for motivating this 40-something year-old to conquer what seemed like an insurmountable goal of swimming 1 mile in the open ocean. I couldn't imagine attempting to swim 21 plus miles in cold ocean water with strong currents even at my age.
During your much needed time of rest, you might want to consider a change of venue for your world record attempt. The Coronado Islands are 18 miles off of Point Loma (San Diego) in warmer water than you encountered. The Catalina channel is 21 miles off of San Pedro California in warmer water. Completing the latter would give you two out of three of the Triple Crown of marathon swimming (English channel, Catalina channel & the Manhattan Island marathon).
Just food for thought.
John Gray
San Diego

Richard K Shields said...

The Foundation for Physical Therapy would like to congratulate American Physical Therapy Association member Stanley Paris, PT, PhD, FAPTA on his attempt to become the oldest person to cross the English Channel. He is the oldest person on record to attempt to swim across the Channel, and while his attempt was unsuccessful this time, he continues to be an inspiration for his colleagues, the Foundation and APTA staff, and others who have followed him on this incredible journey.

Stanley dedicated his swim and all the months of preparation to raise funds for physical therapy research. The monies that Stanley raised along the way will help the profession he loves continue towards evidence-based practice. These funds will also create possibilities for physical therapist researchers to push the boundaries of science while, most importantly, improving the quality of life and well-being of the patients we serve every day.

-- Richard K Shields, PT, PhD, FAPTA
Foundation for Physical Therapy President

Matt Kellum, USA SPT said...

Dr. Paris your efforts have been a success in promoting the importance of Physical Therapy. To even train for and attempt such a feat takes courage and determination most of us could learn from. I am equally impressed at your athleticism given your seemingly youthful age. Take care and good luck on the next attempt.

Patrice Wilson said...

Congratulations on your first attempt! I'm sure you will do much better next time. 7 hours? I am very proud of what you are doing for Physical Therapy and hope to someday have made an impact that is as great as yours.

Tim said...

Stan you are the Man,
Absolutely brilliant! I am hoping for your criteria to met in early September. Either way thanks for all you do.
Tim Flynn

RichardKS said...

Stanley: what an amazing effort. I was privileged to meet with while working on the Destination Research Excellence campaign for the Foundation, and witnessed how much your commitment inspired donors at the CSM conference in Nashville. You seem to have a very rational analysis of why this attempt didn't work out, and a clear set of criteria for whether to make another attempt. Best wishes for your next attempt if the circumstances align favorably.

Mark said...

ok Stanley
lets gets few things straight here, when we did that 6 hour swim in terrible conditions we both agreed in would be feeble to attempt a start on a day like that, did however start and made it over half way, you did not fail, it was another training swim for you, you have invested a great deal of time and effort in this, the water has warmed and is continuing to do so, by sept it will be up to 18C or 65F, I know you acn do this yes you are disappointed, be more hydratedm the cramps will go and you will meet those bare chested maidens of that I am sure. it is booked so you have nothing to lose, it is doable and you know you are the man to do it. see you soon, please dont be sad, you did great under the circs

regards Mark and Kelly

Clara said...

Hi Stanley,

I just finished a swim today with Eric Hartley (who I believe was your boater), and I was on the support crew of a friend of mine with Fred Mardle on the day you swam. The observer was telling us about the other CSA swimmers in the water on Saturday, and our whole crew was pulling for you! We were disappointed to hear that you had been pulled from the water, but I am glad to hear that you have a date to try again. I know it's got to feel awful now, but try to think of it as a learning experience. You will definitely be better prepared next time! Best of luck in September, and I will definitely be rooting for you in America!

Clara Bennett

Clara said...

PS I meant to mention, you are definitely to be commended to even be making an attempt at the record, and you should be proud to have made it as far as you did. Also, I think chances are good that the water will be much warmer for you in September... it seems to have been unseasonably cold for July. Good Luck!

David Bennett said...

Congratulations on a valiant attempt.

However, there were a few comments in your post that puzzled me. I've just spent 2 of the last 3 days crewing on the successful crossings by Mallory Mead on July 26 and Clara Bennett on July 28 (see http://swimmingthechannel.blogspot.com/ for details). In particular, you state "my lips were very swollen and not of a healthy color, signifying the onset of hypothermia." I don't think that this is hypothermia. Both Mallory and Clara experienced lip swelling and discoloration due to the salt. In fact, your statement, "I was mentally clear and at my last feed clearly communicated my problems", seems to indicate that you did not have hypothermia. Or at least, it seems unlikely that you had symptoms beyond "mild hypothermia" as described by http://www.princeton.edu/~oa/safety/hypocold.shtml . I suspect that you'll probably be ok as long as you are mentally sharp.

Also, I am slightly puzzled by your temperature values since the Centegrade and Fahrenheit scales. With Mallory, on July 26, we found a pretty constant temperature of 16 C or 60.8 C, and today (July 28), we found temperatures ranging from 16-18 C (60.8-64.4) F.

I discussed your situation with your pilot, Eric Hartley, who was also Clara's pilot, and he also didn't seem to think that you were hypothermic. So, I suspect that you don't have to worry so much about the cold.

John Medeiros said...

Stanley, very inspiring especially since most of us will not put our great toe into 58 degree water!
Bravo! Enjoy! Thanks for advancing the cause of physical therapy worldwide.
John Medeiros

Bruce Stewart (施樸樂) (ブルース・スチュワート) said...

I read about your preparation a few days ago, and so I was eager to find out what happened. I think you learned a great deal from the attempt, which means that in early September you should be a lot better prepared. Surely you cannot let such an opportunity be missed to have another attempt. Plan the next few weeks carefully so you do the optimum amount of training and I hope you can find ways to keep the grease on, and that you won't feel sick next time. All the best.

Ron Meador said...

Stanley-

You didn't quit. You were defeated by the Laws of Nature. What can be more beautiful than that?

You were our Hero yesterday, are today, and will be tomorrow.

Ron Meador

Angie Lewis said...

You are such an inspiration Dr. Paris! I admire your dedication. Rest up and take care.
P.S. As far as finding a food source, have you tried GU? I find it works great for running marathons. One small pouch every 45 minutes.

mo4osman said...

Thank you for all you have done for the physical therapy profession and for us as fellows PTs. We are all so proud of you. Take care of your self .You are a great an inspiration.Mohamed Osman

Anonymous said...

You are every athlete's hero Dr. Paris. Hang in there. Re-group and go out kick this channels a__!!

Signed,
Sitting for MTC this week.

Anonymous said...

Have no regrets if you decide not to try it again. You've had an incredible journey already and have nothing else to prove. Congratulations on your courageous attempt.
Rich Hajduczek, PT, OCS

Anonymous said...

Dear Dr. Paris,
You are a hero, an inspiration, and a source of invaluable information for anyone who is willing to cross the channel. I hope you will try again, but only if the condition permit.

After what you have done, I decided to start my preparations. Perhaps I can become the oldest woman to cross the channel.
Yevgenia Munro

Erin said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Erin said...

Stanley: Erin Greer with HomeCare Magazine here, writing to congratulate you on the bravery of your attempt. I have no doubt that everyone remains quite proud of you, and sees your efforts as nothing short of an accomplishment. Kudos! And here's hoping you DO attempt another go in September.

In the mean time, here is the link to the story I wrote about you in HomeCare. I hope you enjoy: http://homecaremag.com/mag/
conquering_channel_paris/

Anonymous said...

Dear Stanley,
Well done; I am 44 and still wonder if I would have the guts to swim to France.
As for hydration, you should try Penta water as it is the best water that exists and helps ensure that you reach dehydration levels at a later stage than normal tap water.
regards
John

John said...

BOREDOM in the water?! Have you heard about the underwater radio and headphones?! They're quite expensive ($300 to $400 U.S. dollars), but for a long swim, the extra motivation might be well worth it! I'm a third year physical therapy student at the University of Mississippi Medical Center with a degree in exercise physiology. It sounds to me like you had an electrolyte imbalance, which caused the cramping...as you mentioned...I'm sure you know how to handle that! In addition, I would recommend using a wetsuit or drysuit...at least for your lower extremities. While your upper body might not benefit from this, your lower body would stay at a slightly warmer temperature...which could make a big difference. I hope your next attempt will have more success.

Gina and Gary P. said...

Stanley,

I must admit I have a tear in my eye reading all the inspiring notes from our fellow collegues. You are the man, a great inspiration for us all!

What I love about you is that you have strength and conviction for your cause. You have contributed so much to our PT profession, and I just love you for it. Your strength, wisdom and knowledge are amazing.

If you decide to try your September trial ask God to be with you, to help you every stroke. The power of prayer is amazing. I will pray that you can accomplish your desire to be the oldest man to swim the channel. You can do it!

With love and admiration,

Gina and Gary P ( former USA students and MTC's)

Anonymous said...

Dear Paris,
You were denied the swim because the Channel wouldn't let you do it on this occasion.
Yes, try again and believe not that you might fail but that the next time the Channel might let you reach France. It's not you silly, it was mother nature.
Listen to science too though and look for better than tap water.
You did it before and you can try again.
regards
John T

Bob Niklewicz said...

Dear Stanley,

You have inspired many of us not only through your successes that have provided springboards for our careers and profession but by the gall and tenacity you have demonstrated in life to get them in the first place.

This adventure you are currently undertaking epitomizes that passion for goals where lesser people only ask “why?” You cannot successful explain the reason for trying something incomprehensible if the person had to ask the question in the first place.

Though the goal is spectacular the journey is awe inspiring onto itself. Whether a second effort is in your future or not, I thank you for the vicarious rush I have in cheering you on. It is truly outstanding. In any event I salute and congratulate you.

Bob Niklewicz PT DHSc (USA 1998)

Karen St. john said...

BRAVO STANLEY!

What an awesome accomplishment: 7 hours & 40 minutes in sea water requires a tenacious drive and unrelenting determination that few people ever exhibit! You have made PTs & PTAs all over the world proud of you!! Your inspiration to thousands is legendary!!!

You have been an incredible visionary for physical therapy in the USA. I remember in 1975, when I first met you, you were already advocationg a DPT. Thank you so very much for your perpetual persistance that has advanced our profession! And thanks for your driving force for APTA's Foundation!!

May God guide your journey if you go for a second run. Those of us who admire you, will be pulling for you all the way.

BONNE CHANCE! GOD BLESS YOU!!

Karen St. John, PT, MA, MTC

monica said...

Stanley,
Rich and I have wish you all the best, on your journey. (part 2?) We look forward to hearing about the challenges you have encountered. See you some time this summer, on the Cape, of Maine. Hi to Catherine! Monica

Gerry Catapang said...

Dr. Paris,

Congratulations on your first attempt! I have to congratulate you because it really takes a lot of guts just to try what you are hoping to achieve! Knowing you, you are an over-achiever, no question! I am for sure you will achieve this goal and be successful on this endeavor.

Someone smarter than me once said, "It's not the becoming but the OVERCOMING!" For sure, you will overcome this challenge and become successful. Hoping it will be on September 4. Good luck!

Gerry Catapang
Springfield, Missouri
USA DPT Alumni

Anonymous said...

My daughter was in Dover the same time as you and you were the talk of the town. In fact, I believe your pilot was Eric Hartley, who was my daughter's. Though my daughter, 31, had a successful swim (12 hours, 28 minutes), I did learn that the folks in England (and also in Wales, where we traveled afterwards) are impressed by everyone who attempts to swim the Channel because they know its reputation. While you failed short of your personal goal, to the rest of us,particularly those of us who now know the English Channel, you are an amazing hero. Congratulations. Karen Nazor Hill, Chattanooga, TN